Go Between 71, Oct.-Nov. 1998 UN NEWS SECRETARY-GENERAL'S REPORT ON WORK OF UN The United Nations is more responsive, more efficient and more accountable than it was a few years ago, Secretary-General Kofi Annan said in his annual report to the General Assembly on the work of the organization. The report (document A/53/1) covers, among other things: peace and security questions; development cooperation; humanitarian issues, including assistance to refugees; globalization; strengthening the international legal order; and creation of a culture of communication to enable the organization to more coherently and forcefully communicate with its global audience. Mr. Annan said recent experience shows that the quest for international peace and security requires complementary action on security and economic and social fronts. "Human security and equitable and sustainable development turn out to be two sides of the same coin," he said. The report also examined challenges posed by the emerging socio-economic forces and forms of globalization, and how they should be met to serve the needs of the international community. Multilateral institutions such as the United Nations have a critical role to play in bridging the gap between the beneficial effects of market forces and their negative consequences. The task ahead, according to Mr. Annan, is to harness the positive potential of globalization while managing its adverse effects. Strengthening multilateral institutions can help to accomplish that task. Mr. Annan observed that the intimate relationship between social justice, material well-being and peace must be taken into account in any action to prevent local conflicts from escalating and spilling over into the international arena. United Nations efforts to reduce poverty and promote development and democratization including electoral assistance and civic education have gradually become more comprehensive and more integrated. All of those efforts might be described as "preventive peace-building" since they attack the root causes of many conflicts. Good governance is perhaps the single most important factor in eradicating poverty and promoting development, the Secretary-General stated, adding that support for it has become an increasingly important element in the development-related work of the United Nations. During the past year, tangible results have been recorded in the humanitarian field despite serious funding constraints. In July 1998, for the first time, the Economic and Social Council included a special humanitarian segment in its regular session, in which it reaffirmed the importance of respect for international humanitarian law and principles, endorsed the work of the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, and set out specific goals for future priority areas. Placing communications at the heart of the strategic management of the organization is central to the ongoing revitalization of the United Nations, said the report. If the goals of the revitalization are to be understood, a culture of communication must pervade the entire organization. To that end, a strategic communications planning group has been created within the Department of Public Information (DPI) to assist the Under-Secretary-General in setting goals and strategies and in reaching out to the media, NGOs, academic institutions, the business community and youth. In the countdown to the new century, the Secretary-General said his reform programme must be carried forward, and member states must engage those reforms that lie within their purview with greater determination and vigour. Reforming the United Nations institutional machinery is but a first step toward refashioning its role for the new era. "We all need a vital and effective United Nations," he said, "this indispensable instrument for achieving our common goals, this unique expression of our common humanity." SG'S REPORT ON UN ARRANGEMENTS FOR NGOS In July UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan issued a report on Arrangements and Practices for the Interaction of Non-Governmental Organizations in All Activities of the United Nations System, for consideration by the General Assembly at its 53rd session. "In the aftermath of the global conferences and with the emergence of a new international environment characterized by unrestricted flows of information," said the report, "the United Nations has entered a new era in its relations with NGOs and other civil society actors....The United Nations is committed to seek the participation and contribution of NGOs in its work. New approaches, attitudes, methods and responses are required throughout the United Nations system if we are to meet this challenge effectively." The report, compiled by the Executive Office of the Secretary-General, describes existing arrangements and practices for UN/NGO interaction throughout the UN system. It also addresses some legal and financial implications of modifications in the current arrangements and explores the question of participation of NGOs from all regions, in particular from developing countries. The report discusses relations and cooperation between NGOs and many of the departments, agencies, funds and programmes of the UN system including NGLS, which is described as a "very important mechanism for the dissemination of information and the fostering of a greater understanding and dialogue between the United Nations and NGOs." Proposals toward enhancing participation of NGOs in all areas of the UN system include: harmonize existing UN databases on NGOs to facilitate exchange and compilation of information on NGOs across the system; ensure that NGO sections and liaison offices are appropriately staffed and allocated the necessary logistical and financial resources; and share best practices and experiences to promote coherence and efficiency in dealings with civil society. The report, which cites UN efforts to expand information dissemination through the Internet, also requests member states to consider additional measures such as allowing NGOs with consultative status to occupy seats in the GA during public debates on items in social or economic fields; establishing a trust fund to facilitate participation of NGOs from developing countries in UN activities; and reviewing funding for the UN's optical disk system (see Go Between 64) to allow for wider access by NGOs. The question of NGO participation in all areas of the UN's work was originally raised in the context of a review by the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) of its resolution 1296 (XLIV). At that time ECOSOC members recommended to the General Assembly that it undertake a broader, system-wide review of the UN/NGO relationship (see NGLS Roundup, November 1996). Contact: The report (A/53/170) will be made available on the UN website (www.un.org/ga/documents/select.htm). If you do not have access to the Internet or would like a copy of the report in a language other than English, contact NGLS in New York. Please specify if you prefer to receive the report in English electronically. PROTECTING HUMANITARIAN ASSISTANCE On 29 September UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan's report on The Protection of Humanitarian Assistance to Refugees and Others in Conflict Situations was submitted to the Security Council. The report sets outs the challenges and obstacles that confront humanitarian agencies operating in violent and dangerous environments. "Operating on the front lines of numerous conflicts," said Deputy Secretary-General Louise Frechette, who introduced the report, "humanitarian agencies are all too aware that their ability to be effective to staunch suffering is extremely limited when defenceless civilians are deliberately targeted and access to humanitarian assistance is denied." She said never before have there been such widespread and deliberate attacks against civilians. Terrorized and traumatized by armed violence, millions are obliged to flee and become refugees or internally displaced. "This phenomenon of directly targeting civilians," said Ms. Frechette, "and the use of scorched earth tactics, is not new but the scale of such atrocities, and the horrendous cost in human suffering, has reached an unprecedented level." Among other things, the report proposes what should be done to protect the millions who are internally displaced or trapped in war zones, and it sets out specific measures to enhance the protection of refugees. Ms. Frechette stressed that securing a durable peace is the most important role of the Security Council, and represents the best support it can provide to humanitarian agencies struggling with the humanitarian consequences of warfare. The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) was instrumental in preparing the report, which also benefited from consultation with other United Nations humanitarian agencies. DISARMAMENT CONFERENCE 1998 SESSION The Conference on Disarmament, the world's only multilateral forum for disarmament negotiations, concluded its 1998 session on 8 September in Geneva. During the session the conference examined the following agenda items: cessation of the nuclear arms race and nuclear disarmament; prevention of nuclear war; prevention of an arms race in outer space; effective international arrangements to assure nonnuclear-weapon states against the use or threat of use of nuclear weapons; new types of weapons of mass destruction and new systems of such weapons; a comprehensive programme of disarmament of anti-personnel landmines; and transparency in armaments. In order to examine certain items on its agenda, the conference established two ad hoc committees on fissile material and negative security assurances, and it appointed three special coordinators on anti-personnel landmines, prevention of an arms race in outer space, and transparency in armaments. Three other special coordinators were appointed to consider the improvement and effective functioning of the conference, review of the agenda, and expansion of membership. Contact: Conference on Disarmament, Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/907 3441, fax +41-22/917 0034. UNHCR EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE SESSION At the 49th session of the Executive Committee of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), held 5-9 October in Geneva, High Commissioner Sadako Ogata called for closer international cooperation to resolve refugee problems and stressed that "asylum remains the cornerstone of refugee protection." Ms. Ogata said that international solidarity is needed more than ever to halt the conflicts that cause so many to flee, and to shore up fragile peace in many countries. She also urged development of a "global solidarity agenda" for the next millennium. Ms. Ogata told the 53 member states of the committee that while the number of conflicts around the world continue to increase and their causes become more complex, "political interest in resolving some crises seems to be receding." She deplored what she called an "increased trend toward violence against civilians," and underlined the sharing of responsibilities toward people uprooted by conflict and persecution as "the most significant aspect of burden-sharing." She said that due to budget constraints, UNHCR is shedding more than 1000 jobs. The High Commissioner also expressed concern that in industrialized and developing countries alike governments are adopting more restrictive asylum policies and resorting to a narrower interpretation of refugee law. She called for confidence in asylum to be restored, and reminded governments that "asylum is often the only tool left to the international community to rescue a life in danger." In a concluding document, among other things, the Executive Committee denounced what it described as "numerous and serious breaches" of international refugee law and basic human rights and fundamental freedoms, and it highlighted the unique role of UNHCR in ensuring refugee protection. The committee stressed that the world must work together to tackle refugee issues and must do more to help countries that host large refugee populations to ease the social, economic and environmental burdens. The committee, which sharply condemned the practice of "refoulement," emphasized the importance of the institution of asylum. It criticized the arbitrary detention of asylum-seekers practised in many countries, arguing that persons asking for asylum should not be detained simply because of illegal entry nor held with common criminals. It also called upon governments to do more to ensure the unity of refugee families. The committee said it was deeply concerned about the increasing use of war and violence as a means to carry out persecutory policies against groups targeted on account of their race, religion, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion. Lack of respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, as well as absence of the rule of law in many parts of the world, are at the root of many refugee crises, according to the committee. It urged nations to prevent refugee flows by promoting tolerance and combating racism, discrimination and xenophobia. The committee also reiterated that for most refugees, return to their homes is the best solution as soon as it is safe and feasible. However it observed that for some refugee groups, local integration or resettlement to other countries may be the only options. Noting that in many cases refugees return to societies traumatized by war, the committee urged UNHCR to take an active role in rebuilding and reconciling these communities. In addition it highlighted the need to work with women and children in particular in order to overcome the rifts that lead to conflict. The High Commissioner echoed this in her concluding remarks by drawing attention to the need to help societies recover from the effects of conflict in order to ensure the reintegration of returning refugees and to prevent further displacement. Prior to the session, UNHCR held its traditional meeting with NGOs on 30 September-2 October. During the opening panel speakers stressed the increasingly complex environment in which humanitarian organizations operate, the problem of diminishing financial resources, and the importance of partnerships with NGOs. In addition to a discussion on International Protection Including Women and Children, regional briefings were made on Europe and former Yugoslavia; Africa; North Africa and the Middle East; Asia and the Pacific; Central and South West Asia; and the Americas. Contact: Maureen Connelly, NGO Coordinator, UNHCR, Case postale 2500, CH-1211 Geneva 2 D‚p“t, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/739 8985, fax +41-22/733 7309. UNHCR PUSHES FOR RATIFICATION OF CONVENTIONS On 8 October the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) launched a global campaign to encourage states to ratify key international agreements on refugees and stateless persons by the year 2000, when UNHCR will commemorate its 50th anniversary. "This global promotional effort will be a litmus test of solidarity and international cooperation," said Dennis McNamara, UNHCR's top refugee protection official. He called on members of UNHCR's Executive Committee that have not yet ratified the treaties to do so and "lead by example." The agreements include the 1951 Refugee Convention, the cornerstone of refugee protection worldwide. The convention and its 1967 protocol define the status of refugees under international law and the obligation of states to respect the principle of "non-refoulement" (to refrain from sending refugees back to a country or territory where their lives or liberty would be at risk). The 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness are designed to prevent people from being deprived of a nationality. The 1954 convention is designed to help people who risk becoming stateless, for instance when states break up or borders are redrawn. The 1961 convention prohibits states from refusing to recognize the citizenship of people linked to the country through birth, descent or residency. To date 136 countries have ratified the refugee convention or its 1967 protocol, but this figure is low compared to the number of states that have signed other human rights instruments (for example, the Convention on the Rights of the Child has 192 signatories). Ratifications of the Refugee Convention are also geographically unbalanced, with relatively few from nations in Asia and the Middle East. Only 45 states have ratified the Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, and just 19 states have ratified the Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. SECURITY COUNCIL ON EFFECTIVE ARMS EMBARGOES The Security Council, following up its consideration of the UN Secretary-General's 13 April report on the causes of conflict and promotion of durable peace and sustainable development in Africa (see Go Between 69), is seeking to strengthen the effectiveness of its arms embargoes as a means of diminishing their availability. Resolution 1196, adopted by the council on 16 September, encouraged each member state to enact legislation or other legal measures making the violation of arms embargoes established by the council a criminal offence. The resolution also requested the Security Council Committees, established by resolutions imposing arms embargoes in Africa, to include in their annual reports a substantive section on the implementation of arms embargoes, possible violations of their measures, and recommendations for strengthening the effectiveness of arms embargoes. The council expressed its willingness to consider all measures to assist the effective implementation of its arms embargoes, noting measures that might be relevant in consultation with countries concerned, such as inquiries into arms trafficking routes, the follow-up of possible specific violations and the deployment of border or point of entry monitors. The council requested the chairpersons of its committees charged with monitoring arms embargoes in Africa to establish communication with regional and subregional organizations in order to improve the monitoring of arms embargoes through wider and regular exchange of information. These include the Organization of African Unity (OAU) Mechanism for Conflict Prevention, Management and Resolution; the Economic Community of West African States; the UN Standing Advisory Committee on Security Questions in Central Africa; the Southern African Development Community; and the Intergovernmental Authority on Development. The council's resolution also stressed that arms embargoes should have clear objectives and provisions for regular review of the measures, with a view to lifting them when the objectives are met. PRINCIPLES ON INTERNAL DISPLACEMENT In recent years the international community has become increasingly aware of the plight of the internally displaced, numbering some 25 million people worldwide. Internally displaced persons, who do not cross an internationally-recognized state border, are forced or obliged to flee their homes to avoid the effects of armed conflict, situations of generalized violence, violations of human rights, or natural or human-made disasters. The Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement, developed this year by a team of experts and the UN Secretary-General's Special Representative for Internally Displaced Persons, address the specific needs of internally displaced persons worldwide. The principles, which identify the rights and guarantees relevant to the protection of displaced persons, reflect and are consistent with international human rights law and international humanitarian law. They apply to the different phases of displacement including protection against arbitrary displacement, access to protection and assistance during displacement, and guarantees during return or alternative settlement and reintegration. The principles are intended to provide guidance for states when faced with the phenomenon of displacement; for all other authorities, groups and persons in their relations with internally displaced persons; and for intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations. Although not legally binding, the principles are designed to be a persuasive statement that provides practical guidance as well as an instrument for public policy education and consciousness-raising. Among other things, the principles state that: -- internally displaced persons shall enjoy, in full equality, the same rights and freedoms under international and domestic law as do other persons in their country; -- national authorities have the primary duty and responsibility to provide protection and humanitarian assistance to internally displaced persons within their jurisdiction; -- states are under a particular obligation to protect against the displacement of indigenous peoples, minorities, peasants, pastoralists and other groups with a special dependency on and attachment to their lands; -- attacks or other acts of violence against internally displaced persons who do not or no longer participate in hostilities are prohibited in all circumstances; and -- all authorities concerned shall grant and facilitate the free passage of humanitarian assistance and grant persons engaged in the provision of such assistance rapid and unimpeded access to the internally displaced. Contact: Agnes Asekenye-Oonyu, Senior Humanitarian Officer, Africa I Section, Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), United Nations, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 1773, fax +1-212/963 3630, e-mail . UN SEEKS US$54.3 MILLION FOR KOSOVO In September international humanitarian agencies asked donor nations for US$54.3 million to avert a humanitarian catastrophe in Kosovo this winter. "We have to act very quickly since time is running out," said Sadako Ogata, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Nearly 270,000 people have been displaced by the conflict, which has left hundreds dead and more than 100 villages destroyed. The conflict has affected thousands who are too fearful to go back to their homes. "The civilians caught up in this war should be given hope and reassurance," said Sergio Vieira de Mello, UN Under-Secretary-General and head of the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). "Not only the uprooted but also local populations hosting them must be protected and provided with life-saving assistance with the winter just around the corner." The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, United Nations Children's Fund, World Food Programme and World Health Organization are part of the appeal, as well as the United Nations Development Programme, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, the International Organization for Migration and OCHA. ROTTERDAM CONVENTION ADOPTED Senior officials and ministers from almost 100 countries met from 10-11 September in Rotterdam (the Netherlands) at the Conference of Plenipotentiaries on the Convention on the Prior Informed Consent (PIC) Procedure for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade. Participants adopted the Rotterdam Convention, including a resolution on interim arrangements between adoption of the convention and its entry into force. Eighty governments signed the final act and 62 governments, including the European Community, signed the convention which remains open for signature at United Nations headquarters in New York from 12 September 1998 to 10 September 1999. The convention (see Go Between 68) is a means for formally obtaining and disseminating information so that importing countries can decide if they wish to receive future shipments of certain hazardous chemicals, as well as ensuring compliance by exporting countries. A key goal of the convention, which will initially cover 22 pesticides and five industrial chemicals, is also to provide developing countries and countries with economies in transition with technical assistance to develop the necessary infrastructure and capacity to implement the convention's provisions. UNEP and FAO have been designated to jointly provide secretariat services to the convention and in the interim period. Contact: Jim Willis, Director, UNEP Chemicals, 11-13 chemin des An‚mones, CH-1219 Chatelaine, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/917 8183, fax +41-22/797 3460, e-mail , website (irptc.unep.ch/pic/h2.html) or Niek Van der Graaff, Chief, Plant Protection Service, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, I-00100 Rome, Italy, telephone +39-6/5705 3441, fax +39-6/5705 6347, e-mail , website (www.fao.org/pic). CONFERENCE OF MINISTERS RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUTH Representatives of about 160 United Nations member states, attending the first session of the World Conference of Ministers Responsible for Youth, adopted the Lisbon Declaration on Youth Policies and Programmes. The conference, held in Portugal from 8-12 August, was attended by about 2000 representatives of government, the United Nations, other intergovernmental organizations and NGOs. Among other things, the declaration recognizes that "youth are a positive force in society and have enormous potential for contributing to development and the advancement of societies." It highlights the urgency to create more and better jobs for young women and men, and the central role of youth employment in facilitating the transition from school to work "thereby reducing crime and drug abuse and ensuring participation and social cohesion." It also notes with concern the situation of youth living in poverty, as well as the special difficulties experienced by youth involved in or affected by violence, sexual abuse, armed conflict, disabilities and ethnic and cultural minorities, among other things. The declaration also elaborates actions to which governments committed themselves in the following areas: national youth policy, participation, development, peace, education employment, health, and drug and substance abuse. Contact: William D. Angel, Officer-in-Charge, Youth Unit, Division for Social Policy and Development, United Nations, Room DC2-1318, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 2791, fax +1-212/963 3062, e-mail . UNESCO WORLD CONFERENCE ON HIGHER EDUCATION A world declaration on the missions and challenges facing higher education and a Framework for Priority Action for Higher Education in the 21st Century were adopted by the World Conference on Higher Education, held in Paris from 5-9 October. The conference, whose four major themes were relevance; quality; international cooperation; and management and financing, was held at the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). The event brought together 115 ministers in charge of higher education and national delegations from over 180 UNESCO member states and the United States. Participants also included representatives of NGOs, teachers, students, educational experts, research organizations, international organizations and development banks. The aim of the conference was to contribute to the progress of higher education in the areas of broadening access to higher education based on merit and quality; improving management of higher education in terms of relevance and quality; and strengthening links to the world of work with long-term strategies emphasizing societal needs, including unemployment. Contact: Unit for the World Conference on Higher Education, Division of Higher Education, UNESCO, 7 place de Fontenoy, F-75352 Paris 07 SP, France, telephone +33-1/45 68 10 95, fax +33-1/45 68 56 26, e-mail . TRIBUNAL SETS PRECEDENT ON GENOCIDE AND RAPE On 2 September the Arusha-based International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda convicted Jean-Paul Akayesu, former mayor of the Rwandan town of Taba, on nine counts of genocide. The verdict, the first handed down by the tribunal, represents the first conviction for genocide by an international court, the first time that rape has been found to be an act of genocide, and the first time an international court has punished sexual violence in a civil war. The judgement determined that rape and sexual violence "constitute genocide in the same way as any other act as long as they were committed with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a particular group, targeted as such." Mr. Akayesu was found to have encouraged acts of rape and sexual violence against Tutsi women. The verdict was hailed by women's and human rights groups worldwide, which had lobbied governments strenuously to include a range of acts of sexual violence among crimes against humanity in the treaty establishing the permanent International Criminal Court. Rape is considered a violation under the 1949 Geneva Convention, 1948 Genocide Convention and the 1984 Torture Convention, and a crime against humanity under the Nuremberg Charter. However it has only been prosecuted under the Military Tribunal for the Far East (Tokyo Tribunal). According to human rights groups such as Human Rights Watch, the crime "has been dismissed by military and political leaders as a private crime, the ignoble act of the occasional soldier...[and] accepted precisely because it is so commonplace." Both the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and for Rwanda have brought sexual violence charges. The Rwanda Tribunal, which has specifically recruited women to collect testimony about sexual violence, is uniquely well-equipped to collect data about how rape and other gender-based crimes constituted part of the genocide. The Akayesu verdict was followed on 4 September by the sentencing of Jean Kambanda, former Prime Minister of Rwanda, to life imprisonment for six counts of genocide and crimes against humanity. Mr. Kambanda pleaded guilty to all charges at his initial appearance before the tribunal on 1 May. INDONESIA FACES LONG-TERM EMERGENCY The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) has said that multiple threats to the health, well-being and basic education of Indonesia's children constitute an international emergency. Increased humanitarian aid is urgently needed to meet worsening economic and social conditions in the world's fourth-largest nation, according to Carol Bellamy, UNICEF Executive Director. "The fate of millions of Indonesian children and women is at stake," she said. "Some four million Indonesian children below the age of two are already severely malnourished and more than 30% of the country's children are at risk of failing to complete primary school. Civil unrest has lead to egregious violations of human rights. Catastrophic economic collapse, with the local currency worth less than one-fifth its previous value and consumer staples nearly doubled in price, will have an impact on the country for years to come." Ms. Bellamy expressed concern that over US$50 billion in emergency loans to Indonesia by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank and other lending agencies may not be enough to turn things around. "It will take years for Indonesia to recover," she said, "and sustained international aid is critically important to saving the lives of children. The world community must do what is necessary to rescue the potential of Indonesian children through good nutrition and schooling that will enable them to participate in the competitive world of the 21st century." UNICEF is re-orienting its entire programme of cooperation in Indonesia in order to increase responsiveness to the deepening crisis. The organization is placing primary emphasis on directly supporting poor families to meet their basic health, water supply and nutritional needs in the difficult conditions of the current hyper-inflation. UNICEF is collaborating with a number of NGOs in implementing these programmes, and it is working closely with the Indonesian government to ensure that national policies give adequate focus to the rights of children and women. Contact: Madeline Eisner, Media Section, UNICEF, 3 UN Plaza, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/326 7261, fax +1-212/888 7465, e-mail . SECRETARY-GENERAL'S REPORT ON MICROCREDIT A recent report of the United Nations Secretary-General on the role of microcredit in the eradication of poverty has stimulated further discussion on effective ways to tackle the eradication of poverty. (Small-scale or microcredit lending programmes, of which the Grameen Bank of Bangladesh is the most prominent example, rely on lending small amounts of money to small enterprises in agriculture, distribution, crafts, trading and similar activities.) "Some studies show that there are limits to the use of credit as an instrument for poverty eradication," said the report, "including difficulties in identifying the poor and targeting credit to reach the poor. Added to this is the fact that many people, especially the poorest of the poor, are usually not in a position to undertake an economic activity, partly because they lack business skills and even the motivation for business." The report said that total lending levels are still relatively modest despite recent increases in microcredit programmes, and can thus hardly be expected to make a major dent in global poverty. The goal set at the 1997 Microcredit Summit (see Go Between 62) to reach 100 million families by the year 2005 would require an outlay of US$2.5 million. The report stressed the importance of a multifaceted strategy, which includes training, information and access to land, in addition to access to credit. It cautioned against seeing microcredit as a panacea in the face of persistence of poverty worldwide. "The most crucial requirement," it said, "is to perceive microcredit lending as part of a comprehensive programme of support to the small enterprise sector." The report also highlighted the activities of the UN system and non-governmental organizations in support of microcredit, giving emphasis to the World Bank-led Consultative Group to Assist the Poorest. Contact: Iqbal Haji, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations, Room DC2-1350, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 5104, fax +1-212/963 3062, e-mail . The report on Role of Microcredit in the Eradication of Poverty (A/53/223) will be made available on the UN website (www.un.org/ga/documents/select.htm). If you do not have access to Internet or would like a copy of the report in a language other than English, contact NGLS in New York. GLOBAL EFFORTS TO PROTECT OZONE LAYER Efforts to protect the ozone layer received a major boost on 7 October when ten donor countries, meeting in Moscow, committed US$19 million to assist in the closure of the Russian Federation's production facilities for chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and halons by the year 2000. The funds, the result of a special initiative from the World Bank, will be used to compensate producers of these ozone-depleting substances and will supplement US$10 million from the Global Environmental Facility (GEF), which has been made available to assist Russia in meeting its obligations under the Montreal Protocol (see E&D File Treaty Series, No. 9). The Russian Federation produces about 9% of the world production of CFCs and consumes about 6.5%. More importantly, its production capacity is almost half of the world capacity now. Russia was to have phased out its production and consumption of ozone-depleting substances by the end of 1996, but its political and economic transition delayed the phase-out. The GEF, administered by the United Nations Environment Programme, the World Bank and the United Nations Development Programme, has allocated US$60 million to change technologies of the consumer product industries in Russia to ozone-friendly substitutes. Closure of this production sector was considered essential to stop the flow of CFCs to industrialized countries. The project's donors are Austria, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Italy, Japan, Norway, Sweden, the United Kingdom and the United States. Contact: Robert Bisset, Media and Communications Officer, UNEP, PO Box 30552, Nairobi, Kenya, telephone +254-2/623084, fax +254-2/623292, e-mail , website (www.unep.org) or OzonAction Programme, UNEP Industry and Environment Office, Tour Mirabeau, 39-43 Quai Andre-Citro‰n, F-75739 Paris Cedex 15, France, telephone +33-1/44 37 14 50, fax +33-1/44 37 14 74, e-mail , website (www.unepie.org). NEW POLICIES FOR WORLD BANK LOANS In August the World Bank announced a new loan policy that will increase charges on loans made by the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). The IBRD makes loans to creditworthy developing countries, so the change will not affect the poorest countries that borrow exclusively from the International Development Association. The policy applies to loans on which the invitation to negotiate was issued on or after 31 July 1998. Under the new policy: -- the spread that is charged borrowers above the Bank's funding costs will be increased from the current 50 basis points (half of one percent) to 75 basis points (three-fourths of one percent); -- a front-end fee of 100 basis points (one percent of the loan amount) will be added, to be payable when a loan becomes effective; and -- the current commitment charge structure of 75 basis points (of which 50 basis points are normally waived) will be maintained. In recent years, the Bank has often waived 25 basis points of the interest rate spread for countries that service their loans on time. The waiver will be reduced to five points for fiscal year 1999. Before the new loan price policy, IBRD's loan charges were the lowest spread-equivalent package of costs to borrowers when compared to other multilateral development banks such as the Asian Development Bank, Inter-American Development Bank, African Development Bank, and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. The new loan price structure will put the Bank in the mid-range among multilateral development banks. WORLD BANK APPROVES LOAN TO FIGHT AIDS In September the World Bank, one of six co-sponsors of the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), approved the largest loan ever to slow the spread of AIDS and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) in Latin America. The US$165 million loan to Brazil will finance activities to help reduce the incidence of HIV and STD infection, and expand and improve diagnosis, treatment and care of infected persons. As of August 1997, Brazil had the fourth largest number of AIDS cases in the world, with an estimated 116,000 registered cases. The project will expand upon the government's ongoing nationwide campaign to slow the spread of HIV and STDs, which the Bank also helped finance. The government's programme focuses on changing people's behaviours; providing services for high-risk groups; implementing community-based interventions with the help of NGOs; and setting up counselling and testing services. The project will give priority to high-risk groups such as drug users and commercial sex workers but will also reach out to the broader population, particularly through reproductive health services. The total project cost is estimated at US$300 million. UNCTAD CONFERENCE ON AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT Senior government officials from African countries and representatives of international organizations met in Mauritius from 24-25 September at a conference on African Development in Comparative Perspective. The objective of the event, organized by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), was to re-examine international and national policies that could accelerate growth and investment in Africa and translate the continent's recent economic recovery into sustained development. The African economic recovery, which began in 1994, has given grounds for renewed optimism both within and outside the continent. However, the recovery is patchy. It has not been underpinned by a strong investment performance, and it is highly vulnerable to a downturn in commodity prices such as recently took place. Despite multiple adjustment efforts, structural constraints and institutional weaknesses continue to prevent, or limit, domestic economies from improving their supply capacity. Moreover, Africa has continued to receive minimal flows of foreign direct investment. Rapid trade and financial liberalization coupled with the withdrawal of government from agricultural marketing has resulted in a new set of problems for policy makers. The room for manoeuvre by governments is still severely limited by states' foreign debt overhang. The post-Uruguay Round trading environment has limited some policy options, but has also provided new opportunities not yet fully exploited. In this context, a rethinking of international and domestic policy approaches is required in order to translate the current recovery into stronger and sustained growth. This calls for pragmatism, drawing lessons from experience gained during the adjustment programmes, as well as from the earlier drive for national development. Such a process of reflection and stock-taking could be fruitfully animated by putting African development experience in a comparative perspective. The conference aimed to provide such an opportunity, drawing in particular on lessons from experiences in East Asia and elsewhere. Contact: Charles Gore, Technical Adviser, Macroeconomic and Development Policies, Division on Globalization and Development Strategies, UNCTAD, Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/907 5944, fax +41-22/907 0274, e-mail . ILO WORLD EMPLOYMENT REPORT The number of unemployed and underemployed workers around the world has never been higher and will grow by millions more before the end of the year as a result of the financial crisis in Asia and other parts of the world, according to the International Labour Office's (ILO) World Employment Report 1998-99. "The global employment situation is grim, and getting grimmer," said Michel Hansenne, ILO Director General. "The world financial crisis has put immense pressure on globalization, and we fear that many governments may begin turning their backs on much needed economic reforms. But globalization per se is not the problem." Beyond the current financial turmoil, many nations are suffering from long-term employment problems that can be solved only through the combined action of governments, trade unions and employer organizations. Among measures to increase competitiveness, growth and employment in a globalizing world economy, the report stresses the critical role of a high-quality, educated and skilled workforce. Among the highlights of the report are: -- some one billion workers one-third of the world's labour force remain unemployed or underemployed; -- between 25%-30% of the world's workers or between 750 million and 900 million people are underemployed, either working substantially less than full-time but wanting to work longer or earning less than a living wage; and -- some 60 million young people, between the ages of 15 and 24, are in search of work but cannot find it. "The first half of 1998 has actually seen economic growth in many parts of the world," said Mr. Hansenne. "However, this revival, which we anticipated would spur higher jobs growth in all parts of the world, has only cut unemployment and underemployment in the United States, and to a lesser degree in the European Union. Stubbornly persisting high levels of unemployment and underemployment lead to social exclusion of the young and the old, the less skilled, the disabled and ethnic minority groups with a strong bias against women in all categories." The report said that worker training provides the single best way to resolve this problem among unemployed women, youths, workers trapped in the informal sector and other vulnerable groups such as older workers, the long-term unemployed and workers with disabilities. "Nations facing rapid globalization and competitive pressure need to invest in skills development and training in their workforce," it said. "Training and education were at the heart of Southeast Asia's economic miracle and could well provide a way out of under-development and poverty for millions of workers in other parts of the world." Contact: Luis Cabrera, Publications, ILO, 4 route des Morillons, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/799 7584, fax +41-22/799 8578, e-mail . 1999 INTERNATIONAL YEAR OF OLDER PERSONS Events to launch the 1999 International Year of Older Persons were held on 1 October in Geneva, New York and other cities around the world. The theme of the international year, Towards a Society for All Ages, was highlighted at the United Nations in Geneva by Gro Harlem Brundtland, Director General of the World Health Organization (WHO). Among other things, she stressed the importance of awareness raising in improving the quality of older life, and the challenges for governments, civil society and others to respond to the growing increase in the absolute and relative numbers of older people in both developed and developing countries. Projections into the 21st century show that by the year 2020 the number of elderly people worldwide will reach more than 1000 million, with over 700 million in developing countries. The emerging social and public health consequences of population ageing pose new and serious challenges for national and international public health authorities. For example in the majority of developing countries, lack of social security schemes, poverty, continuing urbanization and other factors are contributing to the erosion of traditional forms of care for older people. The key components of recent WHO programmes on population ageing, which stress "healthy ageing," include database strengthening, dissemination of information, advocacy, community-based programmes, research, training and policy development. Awareness among policy- and decision-makers about the speed of population ageing and its health consequences is low, according to WHO, especially in developing countries. National policies on ageing should rely on the results of research aimed at cost-effective public health interventions to improve the quality of life in old age. Such results need to be widely shared among countries. Contact: Alexandre Sidorenko, Coordinator for the International Year of Older Persons, United Nations, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 0500, fax +1-212/963 3062, website (www.un.org./esa/socdev/iyop) or Igor Rozov, Social Change and Mental Health, WHO, 20 avenue Appia, CH-1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/791 2532, fax +41-22/791 4858, e-mail , website (www.who.ch). FAO STRATEGY ON FARM ANIMAL GENETIC RESOURCES With the erosion of animal genetic resources continuing around the world, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) launched in September a new online and offline computer-based system to help countries sustainably use and develop their irreplaceable domestic animal species and breeds. "A major milestone has been reached in the implementation of the Global Strategy for the Management of Farm Animal Genetic Resources with the launch of the second stage of FAO's Domestic Animal Diversity Information System (DAD-IS)," said Keith Hammond, Senior Officer in FAO's Animal Genetic Resources Group. The new stage of DAD-IS is a multi-language system, available on the Internet and on CD-ROM. It operates as a clearinghouse mechanism for the global strategy, providing a vital link among farmers, scientists and policymakers. It will enable them to exchange views, information and experiences, thus helping countries develop strong networks to design and implement cost-effective action plans for managing the genetic resources of all domestic farm species and breeds. "Animal genetic resources are being eroded in both developed and developing countries," according to Mr. Hammond. "The latest information we have indicates that 30% of the world's domestic animal breeds are at risk of extinction." FAO estimates that directly and indirectly, domestic animals supply around 30% of total human requirements for food and agriculture, and about two billion people depend at least partly on them for their livelihoods. DAD-IS includes a databank that currently contains facts and figures on 5300 breeds developed by farmers and animal breeders of 180 countries over the past 12,000 years from just 35 species. Users can obtain information on breed features, population size, location, production and performance characteristics, as well as details of adaptive qualities and preliminary information describing the production environments in which these breeds are developing. "Most adapted animal genetic resources are not being developed to meet the food and agriculture imperatives. Increasing the performance of the majority of the world's livestock, located in the developing world, through genetics will sustainably increase food security and reduce foreign exchange costs," Mr. Hammond said. "The challenge to achieve food security for all is greater now than it has ever been before, with one out of six people in the world currently underfed." A major threat to the diversity of local breeds in developing countries has been the indiscriminate introduction of exotic breeds that do well in developed countries, but require a large and continuous supply of expensive inputs of feeding and health control and are not bred for long life, so important for medium and low input production systems. Frequently these exotic breeds have not reproduced or survived as well in developing countries as locally adapted breeds, which also tend to retain significant genetic diversity that enables them to adapt over time to changing environmental conditions. Contact: John Riddle, Information Officer, FAO, Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, I-00100 Rome, Italy, telephone +39-06/5705 3259, fax +39-06/5705 3699, e-mail . IFAD LATIN AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME The International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) and the Venezuelan Foundation for Training and Applied Research on Agrarian Reform (CIARA) have signed a US$800,000 grant agreement to finance the second phase of the Regional Training Programme in Rural Development. A previous IFAD grant of US$1.2 million contributed to the establishment of the training programme in six countries of Latin America and the Caribbean: Brazil, Colombia, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Ecuador and Venezuela. The new grant will be used to improve training services in rural development through already established networks set up during the first phase. It also will go toward generating conditions to ensure sustainability of the training process through development of fundraising activities and the sale of services. Complimentary activities will include publications, development of an information system, exchange visits, meetings with other regional programmes, and improvement of local monitoring and evaluation capabilities and skills. SOUTH-SOUTH SUMMIT PLANNED FOR 1999 The Group of 77 is preparing to mark the new millennium with a summit aimed at reasserting the solidarity of the world's 132 developing nations. Indonesia, which heads the G-77 for 1998, has offered to host the South-South Summit, which is expected to formulate proposals on a new platform for action for developing countries for the year 2000 and beyond. The initiative to convene the summit was taken at the G-77 meeting in Costa Rica in early 1997, and was subsequently endorsed by the annual G-77 ministerial meeting in September 1997. The summit is expected to take place in late 1999, a few months before the proposed UN Millennium General Assembly. The central focus of the summit will be to determine what developing countries can do collectively to improve their development opportunities and defend their interests within the context of globalization, trade liberalization and interdependence. Particular attention will be devoted to the volatility of capital markets, exchange rate fluctuations, uncertainties in resource flows and the cost of borrowing. At a G-77 high-level advisory meeting held in Jakarta (Indonesia) from 10-11 August during which summit plans were elaborated, officials emphasized the need for the UN to become more influential in the international economic arena. They called for the establishment of mechanisms to oversee financial flows, and asked the UN to take a more active role in working for fairer terms of trade between rich and poor countries. In a keynote address Ali Alatas, Minister for Foreign Affairs of Indonesia, noted that "it may be productive...to take a hard look at existing arrangements for monitoring and regulating global capital and investment flows. Your findings would help all of us understand the [economic] crisis and assess whether or not current global arrangements are compatible or commensurate with the requirements for sustained growth and sustainable development." Officials underscored the decline of official development assistance (ODA), both in real terms and as a percentage of donor country gross domestic product (GDP). They noted that this has affected the availability of external resources of low-income countries, which have restricted access to private sources. They also highlighted the importance of directing any official funds, particularly those that come through the UN, to areas and projects in accordance with their own policies and initiatives. Contact: Group of 77, Office of the Chairman, United Nations, Room S-3959, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 0192, fax +1-212/963 3515, e-mail , website (www.g77.org). UN AND NGO NEWS WTO HOLDS FIRST NGO BRIEFING About 20 NGOs attended the World Trade Organization's (WTO) first official briefing session with NGOs, held 28 September at the International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development (ICTSD) in Geneva. The meeting, held after calls for greater transparency at the WTO's second ministerial meeting in May 1998 (see Go Between 69), reviewed outcomes of the dispute settlement body meeting and the General Council special session on future WTO negotiations, held the previous week. Participants also discussed how to best conduct NGO briefings in the future, including how to ensure that NGOs not based in Geneva could have rapid access to information disclosed at the briefings. A representative of ICTSD said the Bridges Weekly Trade News Digest (see contacts below) will announce and report on all future WTO briefings for NGOs. Peter Pederson, WTO External Relations Officer, outlined other secretariat initiatives to improve relations with NGOs such as upgrading information for them on the WTO website and circulating NGO documents to member states. Contact: Peter Pederson, External Relations Officer, WTO, Centre William Rappart, 154 rue de Lausanne, Case postale, CH-1211 Geneva 21, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/739 5848, fax +41-22/739 5777, website (www.wto.org) or Andrew Crosby, Programme Director, ICTSD, 13 chemin des An‚mones, CH-1219 Chƒtelaine (Geneva), Switzerland, telephone +41-22/979 9492, fax +41-22/979 9093, e-mail , website (www.ictsd.org). INTER-AFRICAN FOREIGN DEBT CONFERENCE An Inter-African Foreign Debt Conference, organized by the Mozambique Debt Working Group, was held in Maputo from 31 August-2 September. The conference brought together more than 90 participants representing African and Northern civil society organizations (CSOs), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank, the United Nations and donor agencies, intergovernmental organizations, and government representatives from Mozambique and Uganda. Participants recognized that while there are differences regarding development policies among CSOs, governments and lending institutions, they all agreed that debt repayments should not undermine fulfilment of human needs and rights including the right to food, shelter, clothing, health, education, and a secure, safe and sustainable environment for human development and growth. Gra‡a Machel, former Education Minister of Mozambique, said that "creditors must accept that the debt is unpayable and therefore must be cancelled." She noted that while debt cancellation would cost creditors in the short-term, they would benefit in the medium- and long-term and therefore should be seen as an investment in a new partnership. Ms. Machel also argued for greater involvement of civil society in deciding on the use of funds released through debt cancellation. CSO representatives also emphasized the necessity of people's participation in debt negotiations, as embodied in the Arusha Charter for Popular Participation, and they pointed out that political will is key in the effort to eliminate Africa's debt. The World Bank/IMF Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative was singled out for criticism by CSO participants, who stated that it will fail to achieve genuine debt sustainability in Africa "because many countries were left out, others were declared sustainable, and only several had qualified for a questionable level of debt relief before the year 2000" (see Go Between 60). CSOs also said that HIPC eligibility formulas ensure that countries that do qualify are obliged to service debt repayment at a "sustainable" level, which went beyond their ability to safeguard their own development priorities and needs. They said human development indicators are not considered in the debt sustainability analysis. Jubilee 2000, a coalition of CSOs working toward debt eradication, said Mozambique, seen as a test case for the HIPC, has gained little from the debt relief. The coalition said that Mozambique continues to spend as much on debt service as on health and education combined. Contacts: Mozambique Debt Working Group, Avenida Ahmed Sekou Touri, 1957 CP 2223, Maputo, Mozambique, fax +258-1/423140, e-mail or Jubilee 2000 Coalition, PO Box 100, London SE1 7RT, United Kingdom, telephone +44-171/401 999, fax +44-171/401 3999, e-mail , website (www.oneworld.org/jubilee2000/). DEBT NETWORK LAUNCHED A regional organization known as the Economic Community of West African States Network on Debt and Development (ECONDAD) was launched at a conference held 26-28 August in Djeregbe (Benin). The network, which will represent civil society in 16 West African countries, will focus on debt and development issues; disseminate information to members through campaigns, lobbying and advocacy; and encourage NGOs to promote conversion of debts in their respective countries to enhance development. The secretariat of the network will be hosted by the African Network for Economic and Environmental Justice (ANEEJ) office in Benin City (Nigeria). Participants at the conference requested the World Bank and International Monetary Fund to review the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative with a view to making it more "development-friendly and to actually tackle poverty." Among other things, participants said: -- human development should take priority over debt payments; -- the concept of sustainability should be broadened to embrace human development and the basic needs approach and take account of resource requirements for meeting basic needs, such as education and health, in calculating sustainability or the ability to serve debt; -- more genuine ownership by debtor countries and participation of civil society in reform policy design and implementation is needed to ensure compliance with conditionalities; and -- regular monitoring and evaluation of use of the funds available from debt relief could be made more efficient if members of "civil society, especially genuine NGOs, are made use of. This would not only be less costly, it would also avoid window dressing' by government officials when they know a [monitoring or evaluation] team is about to visit a country." The conference was organized by ANEEJ in collaboration with the Pan African Centre for Social Prospects and the European Network on Debt and Development (EURODAD), with support from the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and Oxfam-UK. Contact: David Ugolor, Coordinator, ECONDAD, c/o ANEEJ Secretariat, 61 2nd Cementry Road, PO Box 301, Uzebu Quarters, Benin City, Edo State, Nigeria, telephone +234-52/258748, fax +234-52/250668, e-mail . ADVOCATES FOR AFRICAN FOOD SECURITY BRIEFING On 15 September the Advocates for African Food Security, a coalition of UN agencies, governmental organizations and NGOs, convened a meeting in New York on Food Security as a Human Right. Speakers included the coalition's new convenor, Bani Dugal Gujral of the Baha'i International Community, who moderated a country perspectives discussion that underscored the concept of food as a human right and included practical actions to be taken. Linda Elswick of the International Partners for Sustainable Agriculture spoke on the adequacy and stability of food supply and sustaining access. She emphasized the need to consider not only the quantity of food available but the quality, and the need to practice sustainable agriculture at a time when monoculture and other unsustainable practices are widespread. Ruth Engo, co-founder of the coalition, briefed participants on the group's history and provided a definition of food security in the context of human rights. Peter Mann of World Hunger Year discussed ways to ensure that international recommendations on food security are implemented at the national level. The coalition, established in 1986 during the General Assembly special session on the critical economic situation in Africa, aims to raise awareness of the contributions African women make to their nation's food security. It also advocates for policies and programmes that effectively reduce the workloads of African women farmers while increasing their productivity. From 1992-1996, the coalition organized symposia in New York on different aspects of food security. It successfully worked with delegates to have language adopted on the subject, including the need for resources and land, in the New Agenda for the Development of Africa (NADAF). During the mid-term review of NADAF in 1996, the coalition and the larger NGO community successfully persuaded UN member states to include in their report recommendations on the necessity of making food security one of the key issues of African development. Contact: Bani Dugal Gujral, Baha'i International Community, UN Office, 866 UN Plaza, Suite 120, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/803 2500, fax +1-212/803 2566, e-mail . MEETING ON DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN Five comprehensive regional studies addressing domestic violence against women were the subject of a United Nations expert group meeting, held in New York from 18-20 August. The meeting was hosted by the United Nations Division for the Advancement of Women (DAW) of the Department of Economic and Social Affairs. The experts, each of whom authored one of the five studies, concluded the second phase of a global project on domestic violence against women. The project, which is a collaborative effort by Equality Now, a United States-based international women's rights organization and the Division for the Advancement of Women, was funded by the Trust Fund in Support of Actions to Eliminate Violence Against Women, which is administered by the United Nations Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM). The final outcome of the project will be a special publication outlining measures and best practices introduced at the national level to address domestic violence and identify innovative strategies for the future. During the project's first phase, which began earlier this year, studies were prepared by the experts covering five regions of the world: Africa, Asia and the Pacific, Latin America and the Caribbean, Western Asia, and Central and Eastern Europe. The overall objective of the project is to direct governments, regional bodies and civil society, including NGOs, toward effective strategies at the national level. Its focus is on evaluation of the impact of those strategies in eliminating domestic violence against women. Contact: Jane Connors, Chief, Women's Rights Unit, DAW, United Nations, New York NY 10017, United States, fax +1-212/963 3463, e-mail . SIXTH ANNUAL CLEAN UP THE WORLD CAMPAIGN The sixth annual Clean Up the World Campaign took place from 18-20 September in villages, towns and cities around the world. The campaign, organized in conjunction with the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), receives grassroots support in more than 120 countries with more than 40 million volunteers. The campaign's organizing committees help establish recycling centres, carry out environmental education campaigns, create reforestation programmes and establish compost centres. "The Clean Up the World Campaign is a global success story," said Klaus T”pfer, UNEP Executive Director. "The campaign has also established that the achievement of every single individual in the defence of the environment, though significant when assessed alone, becomes monumental when the global community acts in unison." Clean Up the World was founded in 1993 by Ian Kiernan, an Australian. In support of the 1998 United Nations International Year of the Ocean, he urged volunteers to focus efforts on cleaning their local beaches, rivers, canals and creeks in order to stem the flow of pollution in the world's oceans. Activities varied from underwater clean-up by divers in the Maldives to that of archaeological sites in Italy. Contact: Clean Up the World, 117 Harris St. Pyrmont, Sydney NSW 2009, Australia, telephone +61-2/9692 0700, fax +61-2/9692 0761, e-mail , website (www.cleanuptheworld.org.au/). FINANCING CLEANER PRODUCTION Recognizing the importance of financing cleaner and safer production investments in developing countries working toward achieving sustainable development, Norway is supporting a three-year project in five countries: Guatemala, Nicaragua, Tanzania, Viet Nam and Zimbabwe. The project will be coordinated by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) in cooperation with the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), World Bank, International Finance Corporation, United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), International Labour Organization (ILO) and the International Chamber of Commerce. Projects in the five countries, all with different degrees of industrialization and different environmental problems, will demonstrate how the financing of cleaner production investments can be facilitated, both in existing industrial facilities as well as in new industrial establishments. Contact: UNEP Industry and Environment Office, Tour Mirabeau, 39-43 Quai Andre-Citro‰n, F-75739 Paris Cedex 15, France, telephone +33-1/44 37 14 50 , fax +33-1/44 37 14 74, e-mail , website (www.unepie.org). NGO NEWS NEW CHILD SPONSORSHIP STANDARDS APPROVED The InterAction Executive Committee, which met in September in New York, has approved for consideration a new set of standards that reflect the "best practices" of child sponsorship members. Over the past several years child sponsorship agencies have discussed how to continuously improve the quality of their services, and in 1997 the process was formalized when InterAction created a Child Sponsorship Advisory Panel. Its task was to review programmes and make recommendations on possible additions to InterAction's standards for private voluntary organizations. All six of InterAction's child sponsorship members have agreed to the panel's basic operating principles, which include: -- members that promise or imply benefits to sponsored children in their marketing materials shall have procedures in place to document that children in sponsored families receive the advertised benefits; -- members that pool sponsorship contributions to support child-focused community development projects shall ensure that children in sponsored families are among the principal beneficiaries of the projects; and -- members shall clearly communicate to sponsors their definition of benefit to sponsored children, and shall periodically communicate the indicators used to monitor and evaluate these benefits. The new standards will now be presented for ratification by InterAction's full membership. Contact: InterAction, 1717 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Suite 801, Washington DC 20036, United States, telephone +1-202/667 8227, fax +1-202/667 8236. EUROSTEP PAPER ON EU-ACP NEGOTIATIONS On 28 September the European Solidarity Towards Equal Partnership of People (Eurostep), a network of 22 non-confessional European non-governmental development organizations, launched a position paper on The EU-ACP Negotiations: Goals and Challenges for 2000 at the Development Council of the European Parliament in Brussels (Belgium). When introducing the paper Simon Stocker, Director of Eurostep, stressed the importance of poverty eradication the principal objective in both the European Union and the African, Caribbean and Pacific countries' (ACP) negotiating mandates. He said implementation of the new EU-ACP agreement should be continuously assessed against this objective. Mr. Stocker also outlined what he described as five crucial aspects of the proposed agreement between the two parties: partnership and political dialogue; participation of civil society; trade and investment; investing in social development; and conflict prevention. Among other things, Mr. Stocker said the new agreement should strive to make partnership between the EU and ACP more of a reality than it has been in the past. Among measures needed to ensure this are the recognition of non-state actors such as civil society and the private sector, and facilitation of their involvement as partners in the dialogue. He also said the agreement needs to be more transparent and accessible. Contact: Simon Stocker, Director, Eurostep, 115 rue Stevin, B-1000 Brussels, Belgium, telephone +32-2/231 1659, fax +32-2/231 1659, e-mail . WORLDAID '98 CONFERENCE HELD The second WorldAid conference, held in Geneva from 6-8 October, focused on the impact of unprecedented economic, technological and political change upon the roles, responsibilities and boundaries of the humanitarian aid community. Participants from aid agencies, academic and research institutions, governments, international organizations, NGOs and the private sector participated in sessions focused on the theme of The Future for Aid. Issues discussed included the development dimension in disasters; raising new standards in aid; media, markets and messages in crisis; managing the transition from war to peace; and rebuilding cities, societies and nations. Workshops and other parallel events focused on, among other things, the development dimensions in the El Ni¤o catastrophe; the value of the Internet in crises and relief; and enhancing the effectiveness of food aid. Also organized were a global forum of NGOs for disaster reduction, and meetings of Southern NGOs and networks. Contact: WorldAid 98 Secretariat, PO Box 112, CH-1218 Grand-Saconnex, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/761 1111, fax +41-22/798 0100, e-mail , website (www.worldaid.org). FOCUS TDR 98: FOCUS ON EAST ASIAN CRISIS AND AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT The Trade and Development Report 1998 (TDR), published by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), takes a firm stand against the deflationary response coordinated by the International Monetary Fund in the aftermath of the East Asian crisis. The report also questions some aspects of the structural adjustment policies pursued in Africa and calls for an independent assessment of the sustainability of African debt. LESSONS OF THE EAST ASIAN CRISIS The report says UNCTAD has been warning since 1990 that in the absence of more collective control and guidance over international finance, the structural vulnerability of a deregulated international monetary and financial system carries the potential for an extremely costly crisis. "[The] warnings fell on deaf ears," says the report. "Since then the world economy has witnessed further bouts of financial instability at roughly two-yearly intervals....Each time, the prevailing approaches have been based on the notion of the infallibility of markets and on an explanation of the crisis in terms of misguided domestic policies. Turning a blind eye to the systemic nature of financial instability is neither responsible nor acceptable....Further policy errors may well drive the world economy into deep recession." Economic and Social Impacts of the Crisis According to the report, "modern financial markets are organized less to create wealth and employment than to extract rent by buying and selling second-hand assets, and the discipline' these markets exert on policy-makers reinforces the advantages of existing wealth holders." As financial markets expand and integration deepens, "each episode of crisis comes with greater force, inflicting greater damage on the real economy." East Asian countries, which for years enjoyed annual growth rates of 8%-10%, maintained full employment and made significant achievements toward eradicating poverty, are now suffering a severe economic contraction. In Indonesia, output in 1998 is projected to decline by at least 12% and in the Republic of Korea and Thailand by 6%-8%. Unemployment, underemployment and poverty are reaching alarming levels, and as the crisis drags on it will be increasingly difficult for the "new poor" to recover from deprivation and return to their previous occupations and living standards. The global ramifications of the crisis suggest that the tendency noted in the 1997 edition of the Trade and Development Report of a widening income gap between the North and South (see NGLS Roundup, November 1997) can be expected to continue. "Developing countries are trapped in a corner," says this year's report. "To lessen the risk of contagion, many emerging markets have introduced pre-emptive monetary and fiscal restrictions in an attempt to maintain market confidence and to reduce their vulnerability to a reversal of capital flows. In so doing they have choked domestic demand and lowered growth prospects still further." Critique of the International Response The report argues that the international policy response, because of its deflationary effects, "contributed to the severity of the crisis by failing to appreciate the full gravity of the situation, and by placing too much faith in conventional policy prescriptions." The hike in interest rates not only failed to restore market confidence under conditions of panic, it "added to the woes of debtors, forcing them to cut down on their activity and liquidate assets, while economies were driven into deep recession....External financing was used not to support the domestic currency and stop the exchange rate losses of unhedged debtors, but to maintain convertibility and free capital flows." The report adds that market confidence was not helped by official pronouncements on the alleged structural weaknesses of the economies in crisis. According to the report a major drawback of the type of financial assistance coordinated by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in recent years, which usually comes only after the collapse of the currency, is that the resulting bailouts have been designed to meet the demands of creditors and prevent default. In practice, these measures protect creditors from bearing the costs of their decisions, thus shifting the entire burden to debtors and creating "moral hazard" for creditors. The report also emphasizes potential political reactions to the prevailing approach. "The events of the past year," it says, "should serve to underline the warning in last year's Trade and Development Report of a potential backlash against the contradictions of a globalizing world. When a colossal global market failure and measures taken to bail out creditors are paid for at the expense of the living standards of ordinary people, and of stability and development in the debtor developing countries concerned, who is to say that justice has been served?" Safety net measures can act as a palliative, but they are not a lasting solution, according to the report. Policy should shift from "deflation" to "reflation" by supporting the unemployed through lowering interest rates, expanding liquidity and raising public expenditure, "thus breaking out of a vicious circle that could do incalculable harm." Crises Management and Prevention Given the increasingly private nature of developing countries' external debt coupled with the political obstacles to ever-larger bailouts, the report calls for a very different response to managing financial crises. Appropriate measures, it says, would allow for a standstill on debt servicing to ward off predatory investors and give a country the breathing space needed to design a debt reorganization plan. This in turn would help prevent the initial liquidity crisis from escalating into a solvency crisis. Article VIII of the IMF's Articles of Agreement could provide the legal basis for the application of debt standstills through the imposition of exchange controls if a currency comes under "attack" by speculators. The decision to impose a standstill, which could be taken unilaterally by the nation experiencing a currency attack, would then be submitted for approval to an independent panel rather than the IMF to avoid a conflict of interest with the Fund's shareholders. The report, which explores different means of preventing future financial crises, says strengthened prudential regulation can reduce the likelihood of financial crises. However it notes "experience indicates that, owing to the vulnerability of the financial sector to changes in economic conditions and to unavoidable imperfections in the regulatory process itself, even a state-of-the-art system of financial regulation does not provide fail-safe crisis prevention." The report says elements for a more effective prevention policy framework include adopting an approach to policy surveillance that addresses external factors, such as "unidirectional impulses from changes in the monetary policies of the United States and a few other OECD countries [members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development] which exert a strong influence on capital movements and exchange rates. There are no mechanisms under the existing system of global economic governance for dispute settlement or redress regarding these impulses." Another major tool for financial crisis prevention is the freedom for developing country policy-makers to introduce capital controls a proven technique already used by a number of developed and developing nations for dealing with volatile capital flows. However, the report notes that current global initiatives regarding the international financial system tend to favour the contrary; they "could reduce the autonomy and flexibility of national policymakers in introducing measures needed to protect their economies from volatile and speculative capital flows." In particular, the report refers to the current initiative to reform the IMF's Articles of Agreement to include liberalization of capital movements among the organization's purposes and to provide a formal extension of its jurisdiction to such movements. The report warns that should such an amendment be approved, it could have knock-on effects on the rules of the World Trade Organization (WTO) which stipulate that when a nation has recourse to restrictions to safeguard its balance of payments, these restrictions are to be consistent with its obligations under the IMF's Articles of Agreement. "The proposed extension of the Fund's formal jurisdiction to capital transactions," the report warns, "might thus result in a reduction of countries' existing autonomy regarding control of capital under the WTO regime." In addition to capital controls at the national level, the report encourages regional consultation and collaboration, which it says could play an important role in preventing currency disorders and contagion effects. It also reviews additional proposals for exerting tighter control over international lenders and investors. Some of these would require "new and far-reaching international agreements," it says, "which might be difficult to achieve owing to uncertainties with regard to their effectiveness or to the concentration of power which they would entail." In the absence of global mechanisms for stabilizing capital flows, the report concludes that "flexibility regarding governments' options rather than the imposition of new constraints is required." GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT IN AFRICA The second part of the report focuses on the economic situation in Africa. Since 1995 Africa has been enjoying positive per capita income growth, which peaked at 4.6% in 1996 before dropping to 3.3% in 1997 after two decades of almost continuous economic decline. The report attributes much of this recovery to a 25% rise in non-oil commodity export prices between 1993 and 1996, better weather conditions and diminished civil strife in a number of countries. However, it warns that even if the growth of the past three years could be sustained in the coming decade, "that would not reverse the marginalization of the region or make much dent in widespread poverty, and would do little more than recover the ground lost during the past two decades." Reassessing Adjustment Policies The report says the challenge is turning the recovery into a "stronger and sustained economic take-off, with the aim of attaining the 6 per cent growth target for Africa set by the United Nations." This would require a comprehensive reassessment of policy reforms undertaken in the region, which have emphasized macro-economic stability, a reduced role for the state, greater reliance on market forces, and a rapid opening up to international competition. The report, while acknowledging that greater macro-economic stability and removal of large price distortions have made an important contribution to economic recovery, emphasizes that "despite many years of policy reform, barely any country in the region has successfully completed its adjustment programme with a return to sustained growth. Indeed, the path from adjustment to improved performance is, at best, a rough one and, at worst, a disappointing dead-end." Indeed, only three out of the 15 countries identified by the World Bank as "core adjusters" are now classified by the IMF as "strong performers." The report argues that mainstream assessments of Africa's growth prospects "have almost invariably proved over-optimistic, largely because they have been based on an act of faith in growth-enhancing market forces, rather than on a careful examination of constraints and opportunities." In particular, policy reforms in Africa have failed to bring about what is essential for economic take-off: an investment recovery. "Public investment has borne the brunt of the adjustment impact, but private investment has not, as conventional wisdom might suggest, stepped into the breach," says the report. "Indeed, as a share of [gross domestic product], it is lower than in the 1970s." In addition trade policy reforms have been dominated by concepts of non-distortion, to be attained through low and uniform tariffs "rather than by pragmatism." Imports of luxury and other consumer goods often receive the same treatment as imported intermediate and capital goods, which has created difficulties for domestic firms competing against imports and for enterprises with export potential. Agricultural liberalization has not increased the proportion of export prices received by farmers, because private traders operating in imperfect and underdeveloped markets have captured most of the benefit. Finally, interest rates are high and unstable because financial liberalization has been allowed to take place without first ensuring the conditions for its success. External Constraints The report also argues that mainstream assessments and the policy advice proffered have not always taken proper account of external constraints. In particular declining export prices and a sharp deterioration in external financial conditions in the early 1980s were not offset by rises in official development assistance (ODA), which has accounted for less than 15% of trade losses. The report also points to the "constraints of the new trading regime," which prohibit the use of some key policy tools to promote exports and protect infant industries, such as trade-related subsidies, imposing conditions on foreign direct investment and flexible enforcement of intellectual property rights all of which the report says "were integral parts of the East Asian development strategy." The report recommends African nations use as much as possible exemptions under WTO agreements to provide selective support to industry in a manner that would be time-bound and closely tied to performance criteria. Reassessing African Debt The report, which emphasizes strongly the crippling effects of African debt on long-term growth, says that "Africa's external debt burden is having a severe adverse impact on investment and renewed growth. Not only does it impede public investment in physical and human infrastructure, but also it deters private investment, including foreign investment." The report points out that 80% of Africa's debt is owed to official creditors, a good deal of which it says is simply unpayable. It also stresses that two-thirds of the increase in debt since 1988 has been due to arrears, which by 1996 had reached over US$64 billion or more than one-fourth of total debt stock. Although it says the recent World Bank/IMF Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative is more comprehensive and equitable than earlier debt initiatives, the report argues that debt relief for Africa is still insufficient and too slow. It calls for an urgent assessment of the sustainability of African debt, to be undertaken by an independent body composed of eminent persons experienced in finance and development and appointed by agreement between creditors and debtors. In such an arrangement, creditors would have to commit to implement the recommendations swiftly and fully. Contact: Yilmaz Akyuz, Officer-in-Charge, Macroeconomic and Development Policies Branch, UNCTAD, Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, telephone +41-22/907 5841, fax +41-22/907 0048, e-mail . UNDP: RUNAWAY CONSUMPTION WIDENS GAP BETWEEN RICH, POOR The human consequences of current consumption patterns are unacceptably high according to the Human Development Report 1998, published by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). Gross inequalities in consumption opportunities have excluded over one billion people, who cannot meet their basic consumption requirements. The report also stresses that poor people and poor countries pay most heavily for the environmental costs of over-consumption. Global consumption of goods and services will top US$24 trillion this year, six times the figure for 1975, according to the report. People are consuming more in food, energy, education, transportation, communication and entertainment than ever before. But such figures mask gross inequalities in consumption opportunities. Among the 4.4 billion people who live in developing countries, almost three-fifths live in communities without basic sanitation; almost one-third are without safe drinking water; one-fourth lack adequate housing; one-fifth live beyond the reach of modern health services; and one-fifth of children are undernourished and do not go as far as grade five in school. Runaway Growth in Consumption Runaway growth in consumption is placing unprecedented pressures on the environment through pollution, waste and the growing deterioration of renewables: water, soil, forests, fish and biodiversity. Twenty-five percent of fish stocks are depleted, and another 44% are being fished to their biological limit. Since 1970 wooded areas have fallen from 11.4 square kilometres to 7.3 per 1000 inhabitants. One-sixth of the world's land area is now degraded as a result of overgrazing and poor farming practices. Wild species are becoming extinct at a rate 50-100 times faster than they would naturally. And the global availability of water has dropped from 17,000 cubic metres per capita in 1950 to 7000 today. The report says poor people benefit least and suffer the most painful consequences of unsustainable consumption patterns. Although deforestation is concentrated in developing countries, more than one-half the wood and nearly three-fourths of the resulting paper is used in industrialized countries. Almost one billion people in 40 developing countries rely on fish as their main source of protein, but wasteful marine harvesting and fish processing has pushed up prices and reduced the availability of fish for the poor. One-fifth of the world's people living in the highest-income countries contribute 53% of the carbon dioxide emissions that fuel global warming. The poorest one-fifth contribute just 3% but live in communities that are most vulnerable to coastal flooding. Globalization is integrating consumer markets through "fierce competition to sell to consumers worldwide, with increasingly aggressive advertising." As a result, national boundaries are breaking down in social standards setting. This is creating "global elites" who follow the same consumption styles, reinforcing social exclusion for those who lack the income to keep up with the pressures of "competitive spending." The advertising boom, which now outpaces the growth of the world economy by one-third, also raises serious concerns of consumer rights abuse in the absence of a well-informed consumer base in many countries or well-regulated commercial advertising industries. Agenda for Action According to the report, "the real issue is not consumption itself but its patterns and effects....The strategic choices of rich countries as the world's dominant consumers, will be critical in determining the future." Such choices will include a shift from consuming material goods to consuming services, and adopting technologies that diminish the environmental impact of consumption. The strategic choice facing developing countries, according to the report, is whether they will repeat the industrialization and growth processes of the past century, with inequitable patterns that create a legacy of pollution, or whether they can "leapfrog" to growth patterns that are "pro-environment and pro-poor." The report identifies actions already taken in some poor countries to adopt cheap, effective and less politically contentious anti-pollution policies, dispelling the myth that such possibilities are limited. Five Central Goals The report outlines five central goals that should guide national and international strategies to create an enabling environment for sustainable consumption: -- raise the consumption levels of the more than one billion people who have been left out of the consumption explosion; -- move to more sustainable consumption patterns that reduce environmental damage, improve efficiency in resource use and regenerate renewable resources including freshwater supplies, soil, fish stocks and forests; -- protect and promote the rights of consumers to information, product safety and access to the goods they need; -- discourage patterns of consumption that have a negative impact on society and that reinforce inequalities and poverty; and -- achieve more equitable burden-sharing among nations to diminish and prevent damage to the environment and reduce poverty. Poverty Amidst Affluence The report also introduces innovative poverty measurements for industrial societies. It reveals growing social exclusion and deprivation within the world's richest nations: more than 100 million people have incomes below the poverty line, at least 37 million are unemployed, 100 million are homeless, and almost 200 million have a life expectancy of less than 60 years. "The numbers are shockingly high, amid the affluence," said James Gustave Speth, UNDP Administrator. "More is not invariably better. Progress must be more evenly distributed." In terms of addressing human poverty, Sweden ranks best although it is 13th in terms of average income among the industrialized nations of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The United States ranks last with almost 16.5% of its population living in poverty, although the country enjoys a booming economy, low unemployment and ranks highest in terms of per capita income. "The extent of human poverty has little to do with the average level of income," the report observes. Although the United Kingdom and the Netherlands have similar average incomes, the former has almost twice the percentage of people in poverty. Nations that have managed to reduce disparities have followed a conscious path emphasizing equitable distribution of the benefits of progress. Contact: Division of Public Affairs, UNDP, 1 UN Plaza, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/906 5000, fax +1-212/906 5001, e-mail or UNDP, Geneva Executive Centre, 11-13 chemin des An‚mones, CH-1219 Chƒtelaine (Geneva), Switzerland, telephone +41-22/979 9537, fax +41-22/979 9001. THE STATE OF WORLD POPULATION 1998: THE NEW GENERATIONS More young people than ever are entering their childbearing and working years, according to the United Nations Population Fund's (UNFPA) annual report The State of World Population. At the same time, the number and proportion of people over age 65 are increasing at an unprecedented rate. Our future, says UNFPA, will be shaped by how well families and societies meet the needs of these growing "new generations." Thanks to unprecedented efforts over the last 30 years, the momentum of population growth has slowed, and could slow still further in the coming decades. At the same time, world population is growing at over 80 million a year and will only gradually fall from these levels. In 1987, total world population was five billion; it will pass six billion in 1999, and will continue to grow until at least the middle of the next century. Transformation and Momentum Greater numbers of people are living to older ages, and higher proportions than at any time in the past of most countries' populations are living to at least 60 years. Today there are more than 578 million people over 60, and this generation is growing at an unprecedented rate. At the same time, unprecedented numbers of teenagers, the result of past high fertility, are growing towards adulthood. There are over 1.05 billion young people between 15 and 24 today. The impact of these "new generations" will reverberate throughout the 21st century. There are still 71 countries and territories in the world with more than 40% of their population under age 15. Forty-four of these countries are in Africa, 12 in Asia, eight in the Arab States and seven in Latin America. In the least developed countries, the proportion of adolescents aged 10-19 peaked during 1975-1990 at around 45% of the population. "Currently," said the report, "the proportions are 34% (less developed), 19% (more developed) and 43% (least developed)." Young People: Preparing for Life "As the largest-ever generation of young people enters the preparatory stages of adulthood," said the report, "society's obligation to address their educational and health needs is more critical than ever." For example, enabling young women to exercise greater control over their sexual and reproductive lives helps ensure their contribution to development. Early marriage is still the norm in some regions, closing women's opportunities for education and employment; but in most regions fewer adolescents are married than in the past. With a wider gap between puberty and marriage, sexual activity outside marriage has increased. Nevertheless, many in authority are unwilling even to acknowledge teenage sexuality. Poor or missing information, policy barriers, or discouragement by care providers prevent many young people, even married ones, from using protection against unwanted pregnancy or from seeking help from health services. Family planning services, said the report, "must address adolescents and their sexuality openly and honestly, provide more options, sensitive counseling and better information to promote effective use of the most appropriate means of contraception." Intergenerational Relations Demographic change, increases in life expectancy and new economic opportunities are changing people's expectations and relations between generations. Surveys of women of reproductive age show a steady decrease in desired family size, due in part to better access to and knowledge about contraception, as well as to education and higher infant survival rates. "Parents will have fewer children to support them in old age," said the report, "but parents increasingly do not expect that their children will support them, at least financially." A variety of forms of support for the elderly will become more important as people live longer and more independently. More families will have both older and younger dependents. Women provide most care to elderly family members, but this support is eroding as more daughters and daughters-in-law are going to work. The concept of retirement is also changing. In less developed countries, few older people especially women occupy formal sector jobs in which the concept is meaningful. "A trend towards earlier retirement in industrialized countries has recently reversed," observed the report, "while growing numbers of older persons engage in part-time work or volunteer activities." Many industrialized countries, concerned that the large new generation of older people will strain public-sector pension funds and health systems, are considering social security reforms such as increasing the age of eligibility, raising contributions and introducing private-sector financing. Extending Life and Health By 2150, projected life expectancies in developed countries will be 87.5 years for men and 92.5 for women, and in developing countries nearly 82 for men and over 86 for women 21 years longer than today. "Aging populations will strain medical systems in many developing countries," said the report, "which are still struggling to protect the health of younger age groups. The burden of disease will shift to older ages over the next several decades." Deaths from cancers will increase in all regions; in Asia they may exceed deaths from infectious diseases by 2015. The report cautioned that this change does not justify reorienting health services toward treatment of diseases affecting older people, at the expense of improving preventive programmes and services for poorer and less healthy people of all ages. Maximizing Resources for the New Generations The rapid growth of adolescent and elderly population demands a considerable investment in: heath care, including reproductive health information and services; education and job training for the young; and social and financial support for the elderly. Better health, social and financial support services will take the place of large families in providing for old age; encourage smaller, healthier, better-educated families; and enable older people to remain healthy, independent and productive longer. This calls for integrated service delivery, better information systems, better data on medical interventions and preventive measures, and innovative steps to bolster community action and volunteer organizations. Contact: UN Publications, 2 UN Plaza, Room DC2-853, New York NY 10017, United States, fax +1-212/963 3489, e-mail or UN Publications, Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, fax +41-22/917 0027, e-mail , website (www.un.org). WORLD BANK: NEED TO NARROW KNOWLEDGE GAP OF RICH AND POOR The global explosion of knowledge now underway may lift hundreds of millions of the world's poor out of poverty or it may create a widening knowledge gap in which poor countries lag further and further behind, according to the World Bank's World Development Report 1998/99: Knowledge for Development. New communications technology and plummeting computing costs are "shrinking distance and eroding borders and time," said World Bank President James D. Wolfensohn, so that even remote villages can tap into a rapidly expanding global store of knowledge. But the rapid growth of knowledge is also "raising the danger that the poorest countries and communities will fall behind more rapidly than ever before....In our enthusiasm for the Information Super Highway we must not forget the villages and slums without telephones, electricity or safe water, the primary schools without pencils, paper or books. For the poor, the promise of the new information age knowledge for all can seem as remote as a distant star." Knowledge Makes a Difference The report says low national incomes are not the only reason poor countries are less prosperous than richer ones. Many developing countries lack the capability to acquire and adapt the same economic, technical and social knowledge that has spurred many of the world's development success stories. Since creating this know-how is often costly, industrial countries have greater opportunities to use knowledge to obtain better health and rising prosperity for their populations. Fortunately, nations can narrow the knowledge gap by putting in place policies to acquire and adapt knowledge from abroad, and by making the most of indigenous knowledge. This can greatly improve the living standards of their citizens. For example, 40 years ago Ghana had the same per capita income as South Korea. By the early 1990s, Korea's per capita income was six times higher than that of Ghana. Some development experts claim that at least half the disparity can be explained by South Korea's greater success in acquiring and using knowledge. Poor countries also differ from rich in their pursuit of knowledge by having fewer public institutions to safeguard the quality and truth of the information people need to lead healthy, more affluent lives. Often there is no capacity to certify the quality of goods or services, enforce standards and performance, and gather and disseminate key information needed for business transactions. These types of problems especially hurt the poor. The Ingredients of Knowledge The report focuses on two types of knowledge that it says are critical for developing countries. -- "How-to knowledge" such as nutrition, birth control, engineering or accounting. Typically, developing countries have less know-how than industrial countries, and poor people have less know-how than wealthier people. The report argues that closing these knowledge gaps through education, better phone systems and openness to exchanges with foreign countries, including trade can do much to help the world's poorest people improve their lives. -- "Knowledge about attributes or characteristics" such as the quality of a product, diligence of a worker or creditworthiness of a firm. The report, which describes this lack of knowledge as "information problems," argues that this leads to market failures such as lenders' refusal to offer loans to poor people because of the difficulty in assessing their ability to repay. Priorities to Bridge the Gap The report recommends the following three types of action to enable developing countries make the most of knowledge. First, developing countries should adopt policies to narrow the knowledge gaps that separate them from rich countries. These include investing in education, maintaining an open trading regime that brings foreign investment and licensing agreements, removing barriers to competition in the telecommunications sector, and building on and applying indigenous knowledge. Second, governments, multilateral institutions, NGOs and the private sector must work together to strengthen the mechanisms needed to resolve information problems. Examples of such mechanisms include product standards, accounting systems, disclosure requirements, credit reports as well as more innovative approaches to generate information through self-revelation and peer monitoring. Third, governments must recognize that knowledge gaps and information problems cannot be eliminated. Instead, by recognizing that knowledge is at the core of development efforts, policy makers can sometimes discover unexpected solutions to seemingly intractable problems. Success Stories The report offers many examples of how the effective use of knowledge has improved economic growth and people's lives. Often simply narrowing the knowledge gap improving education and bringing knowledge to bear on the problems of daily life can improve the quality of people's lives. For example, in Viet Nam people living in households headed by someone with no education have a poverty rate of 68%. Primary education for the household head brings the rate down to 54%, secondary education to 41%, and university education to 12%. In Costa Rica, life expectancy and infant mortality are on par with many industrial countries, even though incomes are only about one-tenth those in the United States. The report attributes this to a decades-long government effort to provide people with information about sanitation and health, with a focus on prevention. In addition it is now widely recognized that the level of a woman's education is an important factor in the health of her children. In countries as different as Mali, Bolivia, the Philippines and Morocco, infant mortality rates are two to three times higher for the children of women who have no education than they are for the children of women who have a secondary education or higher. Other chapters discuss acquiring knowledge, absorbing knowledge, communicating knowledge, the environment, poverty, and the role of international institutions. o Contact: World Bank, PO Box 960, Herndon VA 20172-0960, United States, telephone +1-703/661-1580, fax +1-703/661-1501, e-mail , website (www.worldbank.org/). IMPACT OF GLOBALIZATION: GENERAL ASSEMBLY HIGH-LEVEL DIALOGUE On 17-18 September, immediately preceding the beginning of its general debate, the 53rd United Nations General Assembly (GA) held a high-level dialogue on the theme of the social and economic impact of globalization and interdependence and their policy implications. Go Between summarizes discussions at the event. The dialogue, the first in an annual series, addressed issues such as the widening disparities in wealth both within and between nations; the long-term social, economic and political impacts of the current financial turbulence in the world economy; possible measures to moderate financial volatility and reduce the risks associated with capital flows; and the role of the UN in addressing problems associated with globalization. Most nations were represented at the dialogue by their finance, development cooperation or foreign ministers. The format included roundtable discussions as well as formal statements in the GA plenary, complemented by informal panels bringing perspectives from civil society, trade unions, academia and the private sector. Most speakers emphasized that halting or reversing globalization is both unrealistic and undesirable. In his summary statement, GA President Didier Opertti (Uruguay) characterized the phenomenon of globalization as "inevitable a reality, not an option." UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, who concurred that there is no prospect of reversing globalization, said that "what has to be done is to devise ways of managing it better." This was echoed by the representative of Indonesia, speaking on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, who noted a "convergence of perception" emerging from the discussion. "The international community," said the representative, "should take urgent steps to manage the force of globalization in order to maximize its benefits and minimize its risks." The Austrian representative, on behalf of the European Union (EU), described a "broad consensus that free trade and large capital movements had brought gain." However, he also recognized that not all countries have benefitted from those gains and noted the need for official development assistance. "The social dimension," he said, "especially a better distribution of growth, must be an integral part of domestic and international policies." Nations in Crisis Discussions also focused on the devastating effects of the recent financial crisis in Asia, which is now engulfing Russia and threatening to spread to Latin America. Government and UN agency representatives described situations of massive unemployment, diminishing health care, thousands of children forced to abandon their education, and thousands of families forced into dire poverty. "Even the more dynamic developing economies," said the Indonesian Minister for Foreign Affairs Ali Alatas, "those that have managed to integrate themselves with the global economy through judicious macro-economic policies and painstaking structural adjustments, have seen the development gains that they earned over the decades crumble in the span of a few weeks. The fact that the Asian crisis has been particularly harsh on those economies that have been liberalizing financial flows and investment for a good number of years should therefore teach a valuable lesson to all of us in the developing world." In addition to the previous high-growth nations that have been hard hit by the financial markets, many governments also stressed the plight of nations that are not in a position to benefit from globalization. They are suffering the consequences of the financial crisis in the form of sharply lower commodity prices, which severely reduced their foreign exchange earnings at a time when official development assistance is stagnant or falling. Role and Capacity of the Nation State While governments reasserted the responsibility of the state for its economic development and the welfare of its citizens, many noted the decreased power of the nation state and stressed the need for international cooperation and more participatory strategies. "As globalization progresses," observed Huguette Labelle, President of the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), "the power and relevance of the nation state, its ability to effect change and guide the course of human events, is diminishing." A representative of Norway observed that "the Asian crisis clearly illustrates the shift in economic powers away from national governments to stock markets and other actors with little or at least unclear responsibility for the common good." International Architecture "The international community is currently engaged in defining an appropriate architecture for the international financial system," noted Dr. Montek Singh Ahluwalia, member of the Planning Commission of India. He cited some widely accepted features of this architecture, including a common set of norms and standards for regulation and supervision of the financial systems of countries, better information and transparency, and more effective surveillance. Mr. Alatas, speaking on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, called for an in-depth study of the world monetary and financial system from the perspective of the requirements of development. Governments also discussed the possible role of the United Nations in addressing challenges posed by globalization and its economic and social impacts. In his closing remarks, Mr. Annan noted the unique and indispensable role that the UN could play. "Its broad mandate, near-universal membership and ability to involve non-state actors," he said, "all make it uniquely well-equipped to help forge a global response to a crisis that is global not only in the geographic sense, but also in the range of issues that it has raised." According to a representative of the United States, "the United Nations system...can be instrumental in helping nations to create the environment for successful globalization by promoting a genuine respect for human rights and core labour standards not only civil and political rights, but the fundamental human rights of each individual to progressive realization of their economic, social and cultural potential." An EU representative noted that "we need a global discussion on a coherent and effective response to the opportunities and challenges of the future. The universality and the broad mandate of the UN make it a unique platform for a dialogue around the concept of global housekeeping." Contact: Press releases reporting on the dialogue (document symbol GA/9437 to 9442) are available on the United Nations website (www.un.org/News/Press). For a copy of the presidential summary of the session, contact NGLS in New York. DPI/NGO EVENT COMMEMORATES HUMAN RIGHTS DECLARATION The theme of the 51st annual Department of Public Information (DPI) and NGO Conference, held at UN headquarters in New York from 14-16 September, was the 50th Anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: From Words to Deeds. Representatives from over 600 NGOs and international organizations attended the conference, which featured 60 speakers representing the UN system, governments, NGOs, academia and the media. In commemoration of the 50th anniversary of the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), which will be officially marked by the United Nations on 10 December, the conference examined the impact of this landmark document on societies around the world and how the more than 60 subsequent human rights covenants and declarations have been implemented and are functioning today. The conference also highlighted the theme of the anniversary, All Human Rights For All, which emphasizes the universality, indivisibility and inter-relationships of all human rights. The President of the 53rd UN General Assembly, Didier Opertti (Uruguay), opened the conference by noting that the UDHR provides humankind with a set of shared goals. While it was born without the legal form of a treaty or convention, the declaration has acquired a moral authority and has established a frame of reference to which the international community can defer. "Beyond nuances and differences of approach," he said, "the concept of universality is the one on which discussion centres, and at the same time the very essence of the extent of application of and compliance with the declaration itself." He observed that the debate about transition from theory to action, the aim of the conference, would have to be resolved in the context of an in-depth review of the UN. "What Jean-Fran‡ois Revel called denial of the universality of rights in favour of juridical and cultural relativism," he said, could become one of the central issues in the process of renewing the United Nations. Need for Partnership UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan emphasized the need for a new partnership between the organization and NGOs that supports democratic participation for decision-making, enables governments to back down from their mistakes, and enables UN fact-finding missions and other mechanisms to operate. Toward this end, he announced that "at long last, 14 years after the idea was first taken up by a United Nations working group, the General Assembly will consider, at its current session, a draft declaration on the protection of human rights defenders." The draft states that everyone has the right to: meet or assembly peacefully; form, join and participate in NGOs; seek and obtain information about human rights; complain about the policies and actions of officials and government bodies; and enjoy unhindered access to and communication with international bodies. Mr. Annan also said it "obligates states to protect those who exercise these rights from violence, threats, retaliation, discrimination or any other arbitrary action." Human Rights, Peace and UDHR Principles Suzanne Mubarak, First Lady of Egypt, stressed the link between human rights and peace. She said it is regrettable that in some instances human rights issues have become a political weapon. Dr. Nafis Sadik, Executive Director of the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), stated that the UDHR has special importance for women whose rights have been given secondary importance. She said that fundamental to freedom of choice are decisions concerning reproductive and sexual health, and freedom from discrimination, coercion and violence. Other areas of special concern are the rights of adolescents and refugees. She also noted that civil society representatives are essential allies in the struggle to protect the rights of all people. In a video-taped message, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson said the 50th anniversary of the UDHR should not be an occasion for celebration but for recommitting to the declaration's principles. She noted that the UDHR was adopted because of a need to emphasize the dignity and worth of the human being. She stressed the interdependence of rights and placed special emphasis on civil and political rights, such as the guarantee to a free trial. A key violation of human rights, she emphasized, is absolute poverty that denies so many rights. Claretta Nesbitt, chair of the DPI/NGO Conference Planning Committee and Elaine Valdov, chair of the DPI/NGO Executive Committee, said that in the context of so many human rights violations it is necessary to hear the stories of those championing the rights of others, and to celebrate the vast numbers of human rights activists and defenders. NGOs, they observed, are key to all human rights teams; they are sources of "early warning," they alert the world community to human rights violations, and provide guidance with their values and ethics. Discussion and Panels Conference participants, after beginning with an overview of human rights issues and of the universality of human rights, discussed the impact of globalization on development. Panels focused on economic and sustainable development, cross-border issues, health and sustainable development, and building and strengthening human rights institutions. The other major theme of the conference was the relationship between human rights and peace. Panels focused on this issue dealt with the role of the international community in prevention of conflicts and human rights abuses, and the post-conflict role of the international community in ensuring respect for human rights. Throughout the conference emphasis was placed on moving "beyond words to deeds." It was in this spirit that practitioners and activists working on human rights issues shared their experiences and offered insight into how to advance the cause of human rights worldwide, including representatives from large NGOs such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and Doctors Without Borders. Other Speakers Other speakers at the conference included Gra‡a Machel, First Lady of South Africa; Danielle Mitterand, former First Lady of France and founder of France Libert‚s; and Mervet Tallawy, Minister of Welfare and Social Affairs of Egypt. Contact: NGO Section, UN Department of Public Information, United Nations, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 7233, fax +1-212/963 2819, website (www.un.org/MoreInfo/ngolink/welcome.htm). INTERGOVERNMENTAL FORUM ON FORESTS MEETS The second session of the Intergovernmental Forum on Forests (IFF-2), held in Geneva on 24 August-4 September, began substantive discussions on issues related to the conservation and sustainable use of forests. The more contentious issues discussed concerned financial resources, trade and environment, technology transfer and the possible start of negotiations on a global convention on forests. The IFF was established by the 1997 UN General Assembly special session on reviewing implementation of the 1992 Earth Summit agreements. Its objectives are to promote and facilitate implementation of the proposals for action of the Intergovernmental Panel on Forests (IPF) and pursue matters left unresolved by the IPF. However, many government and NGO participants at IFF-2 felt the session made little progress on the issues that the IPF had been unable to reach consensus on. Many spoke of a sentiment of d‚j… vu and what some termed "forest fatigue." Financial Resources A number of developed countries called for more effective utilization of existing funds, the need for mobilization of domestic resources, and favourable framework conditions and incentives to promote private sector investments. The G-77 and China said Agenda 21 and the Forest Principles agreed at the Earth Summit should be the basis for discussion on financial resources. Reference in the final text calling for provision of "new and additional resources, including innovative mechanism and/or measures" was bracketed, or not agreed to, at the session's final meeting on the insistence of the European Union. Transfer of Technology The transfer of technology remained a source of disagreement between Northern and Southern government representatives. For instance, text was proposed by the G-77 and China requiring the transfer of environmentally-sound technologies on preferential and concessional terms in accordance with the Forest Principles, but this was bracketed by the United States. Conversely the G-77 and China, fearing decreased focus on North-South technology transfer, opposed a US-proposed text stating that Southern-generated technology may be more applicable than some technologies developed in the North. The United States also bracketed text encouraging countries to develop mechanisms to enable indigenous local communities and forest-dependent groups to realize the benefits of traditional forest-related knowledge, in cooperation with the Convention on Biological Diversity, through the establishment and enforcement of intellectual property rights. Trade and Environment IFF-2 was unable to reach consensus on any of the conclusions and proposals on trade and environment. Delegates tended to agree that trade liberalization may promote economic development, but debated extensively about its ability to reduce environmental degradation. Some proposed that trade liberalization can have positive but also negative effects, and trade policies must be accompanied by effective environmental policies. Delegates also examined issues related to certification and labelling schemes, illegal trade, market access, and the escalation of tariffs on processed wood products. A Global Forest Convention? A number of delegates including Canada, Costa Rica, Argentina and Gabon, supported the start of negotiations on a legally binding instrument. In their view, existing instruments do not adequately address the problems concerning the world's forests. Russia said progress in implementing existing instruments related to forests is hampered by the absence of a comprehensive legally binding instrument. Cameroon stressed the need for better coordination and synergy among the various existing mechanisms and stated that any international arrangement not accompanied by a financial mechanism would be unsuccessful. A number of other delegations, including Brazil and the United States, said it is premature to begin negotiations on a legally binding instrument and called for analysis of the shortcomings of existing arrangements before working on a new instrument. NGOs were strongly opposed to starting negotiations on a global convention on forests that, in their view, would result in agreeing to the lowest common denominator of forest management standards to further commercial interests. Instead, they said efforts should be geared to implementing existing instruments, particularly the biodiversity convention, and to strengthening their compliance mechanisms. NGOs were also suspicious of the motives of forest convention proponents one NGO representative said some of the stronger convention advocates are the same governments that have systematically blocked progress in the implementation of the biodiversity convention. World Commission on Forests During one of the IFF-2 parallel events, the World Commission on Forests and Sustainable Development (WCFSD), established in 1995 and composed of 26 eminent persons from the North and South, made a presentation of its forthcoming final report. The report makes three major recommendations: -- A "Forest Security Council" composed of the 15 most forest-dependent countries should be established to assume leadership in international forest issues. -- A Forest Capital Index (FCI) should be developed to assess country-specific contributions to global environmental services provided by forests. -- A citizen's forum called "Forestrust" should be created to defend the public's interest in forests by enabling communities to organize themselves as watchdogs of sustainable forest policies. Follow-Up Activities The third session of the IFF (IFF-3) will be held in Geneva on 3-14 May 1999. A number of government and NGO events are planned in the interim, including: a global workshop on underlying causes of deforestation and forest degradation on 18-22 January 1999 in San Jos‚ (Costa Rica), based on the outcome of a series of NGO-led regional workshops; a seminar on practical trade-related aspects of sustainable forest management, to be held from 23-25 February 1999 in Geneva; an expert meeting on international arrangements and mechanisms, to be held on 9-12 March 1999 in San Jos‚; and an international expert meeting on protected forest areas, to be held on 15-19 March 1999 in San Juan (Puerto Rico). All these events are intended to contribute to IFF-3. The IFF is to hold a final fourth session before reporting to the Commission on Sustainable Development at its eighth session in 2000. Contact: Jaime Hurtubia, Principal Environment Officer, IFF Secretariat, Division for Sustainable Development, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, 2 UN Plaza, Room DC2-1254, New York NY 10017, United States, telephone +1-212/963 4219, fax +1-212/963 3463. PUBLICATIONS AND ONLINE Directory of NGOs in the Field of Human Settlements The second edition of this directory, which serves as a networking tool for civil society organizations, contains entries from over 1000 NGOs from 105 countries. The entries include contact information, objectives and areas of specialization. The directory contains an index by organization names, acronyms, countries, subjects, and target areas and groups. Available from: United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat), PO Box 30030, Nairobi, Kenya, fax +254-2/624266, website (habitat.unchs.org/home.htm). Fifth Regional Monitoring Report: Education for All? This report, from the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), highlights the serious challenges facing education of children in Central and Eastern Europe, the Commonwealth of Independent States and the Baltic Republics. It aims to promote action through analysis and discussion of critical areas of educational policy and covers issues such as enrolment, learning achievement, schooling costs, education for children with special needs, early childhood development, and the decentralization of educational systems. Available from: International Child Development Centre, UNICEF, 12 Piazza SS Annunziata, I-50122 Florence, Italy, fax +39-55/244817. Ethnic Diversity and Public Policy: A Comparative Inquiry This book, co-published by the United Nations Research Institut